Unraveling the mind: Why We Love Psychological Thrillers

A debut author’s perspective on the Thriller genre’s enduring appeal

As an avid crime fiction fan, I’ve been drawn to the captivating world of psychological thrillers for longer than I can remember. This genre, known for its unique blend of suspense, mystery, and elements of horror, has a special place in the hearts of many book lovers. I’d like to explore some reasons behind the enduring popularity of psychological thrillers and why fans like me can’t get enough of these mind-bending stories.

From bestsellers like “The Housemaid” by Freida McFadden, to recent hits like “None of This is True” by Lisa Jewell, psychological thrillers continue to dominate bestseller lists and capture readers’ imaginations. But what is it about these stories that keeps us coming back for more? Why do we, as fans, find ourselves so deeply engrossed in these often dark and twisted tales?

I’ve got more questions!

  • How do psychological thrillers tap into the complexities of the human psyche?
  • Why does the suspense and unpredictability of these stories keep readers hooked?
  • What is the importance of relatable yet complex characters in the genre?
  • And what makes psychological thrillers so emotionally engaging for readers?

The Psychological Intrigue

One of the primary reasons I love psychological thrillers is their ability to delve deeply into the human mind. These stories often explore the darker aspects of human nature, examining themes of mental and emotional disturbance that both fascinate and unsettle me.

Take, for example, one of Robert Galbraith’s older books Career of Evil. I found myself completely absorbed by Cormoran Strike’s reaction, as an Afghanistan war amputee now working as a private detective, when he receives a severed leg in the mail. It leads Strike and his assistant Robin Ellacott, herself a brutal sexual assault survivor, on the trail of a serial killer with a personal vendetta against Strike.

A picture of figures in a dark forest with a psychological thriller atmosphere.

The way Galbraith, who is in fact J.K. Rowling writing crime fiction under a pen name, masterfully portrays Strike’s and Robin’s mental states in response to this vile serial killer spoke to the complexity of human psychology. (The Strike series now has seven books.)

Psychological thrillers often blur the lines between right and wrong, sanity and madness. They challenge my perceptions and force me to confront uncomfortable truths about human nature. As a reader, I’m not just following a plot; I’m diving into the depths of characters’ minds, trying to understand their motivations, fears, and desires.

This exploration of the human psyche isn’t limited to the characters within the story. Psychological thrillers often prompt me to reflect on my own thoughts and behaviors. They raise questions about morality, identity, and the nature of reality itself. It’s this deep psychological intrigue that keeps me coming back to the genre over and over.

Suspense and Unpredictability

The constant sense of tension and unpredictability, all the twists and turns, provide another captivating aspect of this genre. These novels keep readers like me on the edge of our seats, pulses pounding, and pages turning well into the night.

Behind Her Eyes by Sarah Pinborough is a psychological thriller that masterfully maintains tension and unpredictability through its intricate plot and unexpected twists. The novel revolves around a love triangle involving Louise, a single mother and secretary; David, her new boss; and Adele, David’s wife. The characters are deeply flawed and manipulative.

This manipulation and the characters’ hidden agendas contribute to the novel’s suspenseful atmosphere. The book is renowned for its jaw-dropping twist ending, which redefines the entire narrative. (No spoilers here!)

Similarly, the latest psychological thriller by A.J. Finn, End of Story, is characterized by its complex and layered narrative, which provides steady suspense and unpredictability. The story involves a mystery surrounding a character named Sebastian, whose first wife and teenage son vanished on New Year’s Eve in 1999. This unresolved past creates a backdrop of tension as the protagonist, Nicky, delves into Sebastian’s life to uncover the truth.

The novel is filled with revelations and twists that challenge the reader’s assumptions. The ending, in particular, is described as both fatal and brilliant, reframing the entire narrative in a way that is both surprising and satisfying.

A moody photo featuring two figures in a dark room. Psychological thrillers

The suspense in psychological thrillers often comes from more than just external events. It’s the internal struggles of the characters, the mounting tension in their relationships, and the gradual unraveling of their psyches that create a palpable sense of unease. As a reader, I find myself holding my breath, tensing up, and eagerly anticipating what will happen next.

This combination of suspense and unpredictability creates a reading experience that’s both intellectually stimulating and emotionally gripping. It’s like being on a rollercoaster ride for the mind, never knowing what sharp turn or sudden drop is coming next.

Relatable Yet Complex Characters

One of the most compelling aspects of psychological thrillers is the depth and complexity of their characters. These aren’t simple heroes and villains; they’re flawed, multi-dimensional individuals who often blur the lines between good and bad.

Let’s go back to Cormoran Strike, the protagonist in the series by Robert Galbraith (a pen name of J.K. Rowling). He’s a richly developed character whose complexity adds depth and intrigue to the novels.

Strike is an ex-military police investigator who served in Afghanistan, where he lost part of his leg in a bomb attack. This experience has left him with both physical and emotional scars, contributing to his gritty and resilient nature. His background as the illegitimate son of a famous rock star, Jonny Rokeby, and a super groupie, Leda Strike, adds layers to his personal life, including a strained relationship with his father and a tumultuous upbringing.

What I appreciate most about characters in psychological thrillers is that they’re not always likable, but they’re almost always understandable. Even when I disagree with their choices or find their actions reprehensible, I can usually see the twisted logic or emotional pain driving them.

This relatability adds an extra layer of intrigue to the stories. As I read, I often find myself wondering: What would I do in this situation? How far would I go to protect myself or my loved ones? These characters force me to confront uncomfortable truths about human nature and my own capacity for good and evil. Moreover, the personal struggles and motivations of these complex characters add depth to the overall narrative. Their internal conflicts often mirror or complement the external plot, creating a rich, multi-layered story.

In many psychological thrillers, the characters’ pasts play a crucial role in shaping their present actions. Unraveling their backstories becomes part of the mystery, adding another dimension to the plot. This gradual revelation of character depth keeps me invested in the story, eager to understand the full picture of who these people are and why they do what they do.

The complexity of these characters also allows for nuanced exploration of themes like morality, identity, and the impact of trauma. Through their struggles and choices, psychological thrillers often prompt me to reflect on broader questions about human nature and society.

And so…

As I consider why I and so many others are drawn to psychological thrillers, it becomes clear that the genre’s appeal lies in its unique combination of psychological intrigue, suspense, and complex characters.

The exploration of the human psyche that these novels offer is both fascinating and unsettling. They allow us to delve into the darker aspects of human nature from the safety of our reading nooks, challenging our perceptions and prompting self-reflection.

The suspense and unpredictability keep us engaged, our minds churning to solve the puzzle before the final reveal. The thrill of being constantly on edge, never quite sure what to expect next, is a key part of what makes these stories so addictive.

Finally, the relatable yet complex characters bring depth and emotional resonance to the narratives. They blur the lines between right and wrong, forcing us to confront uncomfortable truths about ourselves and human nature in general.

For me, reading a psychological thriller is more than just entertainment; it’s an immersive experience that challenges my mind, stirs my emotions, and often leaves me pondering long after I’ve turned the final page.

I’m curious to hear from other psychological thriller enthusiasts. What draws you to the genre? Do you have any favorite novels that exemplify the elements I’ve talked about? Let me know below!

TANGLED DARKNESS

A psychological Medical thriller and LGBTQ Mystery Set in Portland

After psychiatrist Leslie Schoen’s coworker turns up dead, she uncovers a web of corruption and battles malevolent forces to expose the truth, confronting past demons to protect her new life with her wife.

Explore the Twisted Web of Lies

Tangled Darkness by MM Desch

SHARE:

Similar Posts

  • |

    First Ten Pages Bootcamp

    During late October and November 2022, I sent out 17 queries. By the time most agencies, agents, and editors were closed down for the Holidays (around Thanksgiving to mid-December), I had 10 rejections filed away. From what I’ve learned from social media sites, receiving a rash of rejections is a good time (especially if you’ve…

  • |

    Update on TANGLED DARKNESS Revisions:

    Some of you may be aware that I took a first ten pages ‘bootcamp’ seminar at the turn of the year. It dovetailed quite nicely with another Manuscript Academy Submission Strategy workshop that taught me a lot about the querying process. Beyond learning how to interpret agent responses to queries, I finished with a new…

  • I’ve Seen So Much

    Originally published on Story Circle Network‘s Her Stories Substack, in the True Words by Real Women section. After I made my Saturday trek over to the senior living facility where my parents lived, I found myself in an unexpected conversation with my almost 90-year-old father. They’d moved into “the Big House” ten years earlier. I’d…

  • |

    Resources for Mental Health and Substance Use Disorders

    Tangled Darkness includes themes of alcoholism, the opioid addiction epidemic, and severe mental illness. In the United States, now more than two years into the pandemic, rates of substance abuse and mental health distress have escalated beyond their pre-pandemic high levels. This entry is designed to provide resources for those who are experiencing problems in…

  • Inside the Author of Tangled Darkness

    This interview was original posted on the Hott Books blog as part of my Virtual Book Tour. What inspired you to write your first book? After leaving a long career in psychiatry, I wanted a creative outlet to explore new territory. During the journaling associated with Caroline Myss’s book, Sacred Contracts: Awakening Your Divine Potential, I…